- ARTICLE: Jayfeather's stick
- START DATE: 14 April 2012
- REASON FOR CONSIDERATION: I really don't think that this stick should have an article to itself. It's significant, yeah, but it isn't the most significant item in the history of the series, and in my opinion it isn't significant enough to warrant having an article to itself. Seems a bit superfluous and it forces us to have to specify when we're talking about the actually character, Stick, instead of the item. Anything we really need to know about this thing is stated in character articles, since it's never seen on its own and is only seen when characters interact with it in some way. For this reason, I think that this article should be deleted.
- PROCESSED BY Shelly For a limited time only 20:20, April 17, 2012 (UTC)
| Cast your vote with the Deletion Discussion Voting Scheme Select the code from the list below that best describes your feelings on the nominated article. You have a single vote, but are free to enter comments and questions as you feel necessary. Voting will be open from DD MONTH YEAR until DD MONTH YEAR. | ||
|---|---|---|
| PICTURE | VOTE CODE | DESCRIPTION |
|
{{voteyay}} ~~~~ | You feel this article should be deleted from the Warriors Wiki. |
|
{{votenay}} ~~~~ | You do not feel this article should be deleted from the Warriors Wiki. |
|
{{question}} ~~~~ TEXT | You are posing a question on the topic. (This may be done in addition to voting, both before & after) (Please enter that question in place of the word 'TEXT') |
|
{{votemerge}} ~~~~ [[NAME]] | You support the merging of this article with another, or moving it to a new location. (Please specify that new location or article by replacing the word 'NAME' in the Wikilinks with the appropriate title.) |
|
{{comment}} ~~~~ TEXT | You are making a comment on the topic. (This may be done in addition to voting, both before & after) (Please enter that question in place of the word 'TEXT') |
|
{{dontvote}} ~~~~ | You are choosing to abstain from voting on this deletion. |
As I'm quite fond of the stick, and it's importance in the PoT arc, as well as it being mentioned in the OotS arc, I don't think it should be deleted. However, perhaps there should be more added to the article or something that makes it less of a hinderace to the wiki. —Jayce(20:35,4/17/2012)
That's a good idea, but I honestly cannot think of anything we could relevantly add to that article. We could make it an article about ghosts or something, since it was revealed that Midnight and Rock were ghosts, a unique title not given to any other apparently dead character. The stick would tie in with that... sort of. Shelly For a limited time only 20:40, April 17, 2012 (UTC)
- Well, perhaps we could elaborate on the importance of the stick, and it's connection to Rock, and by extension, Jayfeather. I'd also be up for making it into an article about things of that nature...or perhaps we could somehow include the Stick in with The Ancients, as last I checked, it was used back in their time. —Jayce(20:45,4/17/2012)
- The Ancients. Merging it into the Ancients page is a great idea. I'd be happy with that. Shelly For a limited time only 05:39, April 18, 2012 (UTC)
- I think mergine it with the Ancients page would be great, since it significant to them the most. ~DJCandyFun~ I do enjoy fun...8D 10:56, 18, 04, 2012
Don't you need to add the dates the vote is open for, since it is currently not shown? ~DJCandyFun~ I do enjoy fun...8D 10:56, 18, 04, 2012
It is a quite important part of both the cats' history and the plot of the third arc, not to mention its cult following, and I imagine that quite a few people use this encyclopedia to look up info on it. Helixtalk 17:44, April 26, 2012 (UTC)
- Totally agree on merging it into the Ancients page. ϚίĿʋεʀϝƪσώȅƦ ♥ Live like there's no tomorrow! ♥ 18:02, April 26, 2012 (UTC)
Agreeing with Helix. I do think this article is needed. But perhaps we could add more to it so there's more information on it. Such as maybe a list of known cats marked on there, and a significance of each, and things like that?
Paleh
Send help 18:28, April 26, 2012 (UTC)
I am also agreeing with Helix. I feel that the article deserves it's own page, because it has an important part in the series. We just need to expand it. RowanOnly One Can Judge... 19:36, April 26, 2012 (UTC)
Agreed. This item is what connects Jayfeather and Rock. And it represents a lot of the history of the Ancient cats. Stoneclaw 01:44, April 27, 2012 (UTC)
>.< Why do the good points have to be pointed out after I've voted. -headdesk- Agreeing with the above. ~DJCandyFun~ I do enjoy fun...8D 06:36, 27, 04, 2012