Forum:Long Shadows 10'

Forums: Index > Wiki Operations > Feature Article Nominations > Long Shadows 10'

COMMENTS FROM NOMINATOR: Actually, Firestar's Quest could still use some expansion as it doesn't cover everything in the story, and isn't very detailed, for a book with 400 pages. We have mangas that are more detailed than that. I am suggesting Long Shadows, as the plot summary is greatly detailed, and it is about to become silver. The only thing is, it could use some praise, and I will try to look into that later. Opinions?

Cast your vote with the Feature Article Voting Scheme Select the code from the list below that best describes your feelings on the nominated article. You have a single vote, but are free to enter comments and questions as you feel necessary. Voting will be open from 26 October 2010 until 2 November 2010.

PICTURE	VOTE CODE	DESCRIPTION
	{{voteyay}} ~~~~	You feel this article deserves to be featured, but does not qualify for gold status.
	{{voteyayq}} ~~~~	You feel this article deserved to be featured and qualifies for gold status.
	{{votenay}} ~~~~	You do not feel this article deserves to be featured.
	{{question}} ~~~~ TEXT	You are posing a question on the topic. (This may be done in addition to voting, both before & after) (Please enter your question in place of the word 'TEXT')
	{{comment}} ~~~~ TEXT	You are making a comment on the topic. (This may be done in addition to voting, both before & after) (Please enter your comment in place of the word 'TEXT')
	{{dontvote}} ~~~~	You are choosing to abstain from voting on this feature.

Looks good enough for gold in my opinion. White Storm is back! 02:27, October 27, 2010 (UTC)

Supporting as a feature but I'd like to see some clarification on the plot summary length before deciding whether to support for gold. Also, am I right in thinking there is no praise available yet? I looked a few months ago but don't know whether anyone has checked more recently. --Sandy^Talk 21:08, October 29, 2010 (UTC)

Sandy, yes you are correct to think that there in praise avaliable. I checked around last week, and did not find any. Also, you are entitled to your own opinion, but I don't think the plot summary length is something to keep this article from becoming gold. I will start a disucssion about plot summary, though, if it makes you happy. :) No offense meant either. :) White Storm is back! 21:36, October 29, 2010 (UTC)

Thanks for clarification on that. Also, it's not about making me happy, it's about doing the best thing for the wiki and the articles. I noticed there was some brief discussion over what the correct length/amount of detail was for a plot summary and see no point in granting an article gold status if later it will not be up to scratch. --Sandy^Talk 21:41, October 29, 2010 (UTC)

The article is good, but I do not have the book to check for its completeness, therefore I cannot support it for gold. In any case, once featured, we can make it gold later. Helix^talk 17:35, October 30, 2010 (UTC)

Same with Helix. ❄Icy❄^{Jingle Bells, Jingle Bells!} 18:49, October 30, 2010 (UTC)

☄ℱrost h e art ϡ Hexakosioi hexekontahexaphobia 21:02, October 30, 2010 (UTC)

Results[]

With five yay votes, Long Shadows will be featured. However, with only two yay votes supporting Gold, it will not be granted Gold status. White Storm is back! 22:38, November 4, 2010 (UTC)