| ||
---|---|---|
|
- ARTICLE: Mistakes in the Warriors Series
- NOMINATED BY —Jayce()
- COMMENTS FROM NOMINATOR: I'll take over on this. I could use a good citing spree.
-Ducksauce 05:10, July 27, 2012 (UTC)
RowanOnly One Can Judge... 05:18, July 27, 2012 (UTC)
—Jayce(05:19,7/27/2012)
User:A Cat Named Cheshire/Sig15:02, July 27, 2012 (UTC)
- Sorry to be a pain here, but there are some unfinished sections in the article (with the CS templates). Shouldn't those be finished? Stoneclaw 19:03, July 27, 2012 (UTC)
Agreed with Stoneclaw. Articles that are made silver should be completed to the most recent of books. If/when the sections are finished, I will then change my vote. Atelda insert vague subtext here 19:07, July 27, 2012 (UTC) However, If there are no mistakes in the book, then shouldn't the section be removed? Stoneclaw 19:09, July 27, 2012 (UTC) Until all sections are finished, I will change my vote. But until then, I agree with Stoneh and Atelda. Sweetflower 19:12, July 27, 2012 (UTC)
- I can't complete what I don't have, guys. I said that I cannot complete the Tigerstar and Sasha sections as I do not own them, and as for the others, they are no mistakes that I can find. The CS templates are there that way they can be added as they are found. e.e —Jayce(18:03,8/1/2012)
- Then this should not be silver and you should have given this article off to someone else or asked for help for those sections. Silver status articles should be complete. Atelda insert vague subtext here 22:04, August 1, 2012 (UTC)
- I did ask. I even said on the nomination that I do not own those books, and asked for someone to fill them in for me. It's not my fault that no one pays attention to the nominations. —Jayce(22:11,8/1/2012)
- If you did ask, then this nomination should have never been CBVed and this vote should never have existed. Atelda insert vague subtext here 22:16, August 1, 2012 (UTC)
- Then someone should have interrupted the CBV and said something. It is not my fault that I do not own the books. The article's still silver, as there are more for votes, than against. The article is more than ready for silver status. The only two sections that have the CS template are the two I cannot complete. Why should I be penalized for something that I cannot control? —Jayce(22:20,8/1/2012)
- No, because you're leader of is project, and you're the nominator of this article. You yourself should have stopped CBV since you knew that you didn't have the books. As a leader of this project, I, as well as rest of the project members, expect that the leader of the project should know that silver nominations are complete. You as the nominator should know too that this article should be complete. Nothing was stopping you from stopping your own nomination's CBV. stop blaming this on other users when you are completely responsible as the nominator and the project leader. Atelda insert vague subtext here 22:34, August 1, 2012 (UTC)
- The nomination passed anyways. And as we type, I'm still looking for mistakes. I looked in the browse inside and found nothing. I've done all that I can. Explain to me why this perfectly good article should be stopped from given a silver ranking just because of (now one) template. I cannot find any mistakes in the second Tigerstar and Sasha book, because I don't own it, and the browse inside only shows the first twenty pages or so. Leader of the project or not, it's not my fault. I'm not blaming anyone. Check the archive yourself. I asked for help. It is not my fault no one bothered. —Jayce(22:40,8/1/2012)
- It's still incomplete and now it's a silver article. Whether or not you ask for help, this was still put to vote. There were several opportunities where you could have stopped the process of an article becoming silver like a responsible nominator and leader. Just because you do not have a book is no excuse to pass an incomplete article to silver status. Also, you are putting blame on others, or at least putting off the blame. You say that it's not your fault for anyone else interrupting th CBV but yet you could have stopped it. On a side note, if there are no mistakes they shouldn't have the CS template on them. Atelda insert vague subtext here 22:52, August 1, 2012 (UTC)
- 'Teldy, I did not know that about the CS template. I stuck it there in case someone would happen to find a mistake. They could add it in as they pleased. I myself, cannot. And now the article is complete. There are no more CS templates. I managed to find one for the third Tigerstar and Sasha book, and removed the second T&S section completely. —Jayce(23:08,8/1/2012)
Conclusion[]
With more supporting votes than against votes, this article will be granted silver grade. (The CS templates are there to add mistakes as they go) Appledash the light of honor 18:02, August 1, 2012 (UTC)