This cat should not have a page he is never seen or talked to anyone. He isn't an important character. We don't even know his name. 126.96.36.199 16:24, July 9, 2011 (UTC)
He's significant enough. He has a page for the same reason that Leafstar's Mother has a page. He's part of the plot, and should be acknowledged. Shelly For a limited time only 00:37, August 2, 2011 (UTC)
- Amberstorm, this is a comment from 2011, and we didn't know back then if he would appear again. This is back when the page was named "Shellheart's Grandfather". — Cloud ( 21:35, 3/20/2016 )
Shouldn't this be named, "Shellheart's Father"?
The passage where Mapleshade was yelling at Crookedstar about his heritage includes a quote from her that says "Oh no! You must listen to the whole story! Their father blamed me! And RiverClan cast me out too. *word skippy* But what made is that the father of my drowned kits took a mate! They had a daughter and she had a son, and do you know who that son was? Shellheart, your father." Just a... thing I think I should bring to life; correct me if I'm wrong.
Ahh, I understand now. I thought Shellheart's granfather had 2 kits, shellheart and Shellheart's mother. Wow, sorry to have inconvenienced you.
Appledusk-light brown tom with feather-soft chest fur and piercing, holly-colored, green eyes.
Shouldnt there be a citation for the 'feather-soft chest fur' description? I get nagged about adding uncited descriptions that arent worth arguing over and now here is something worth arguing over that isnt cited!
We need to have cites so people will know it's not made up or something, or confuse charart with the actual description. The "feather-soft fur" may be on the same page as the pale eyes, so it's worth checking out since I don't own Mapleshade's Vengeance. And why is my text big? o_O --Songheart (talk) 21:48, March 30, 2015 (UTC)Songheart
To answer your last question, Spotted forgot to close her signature. which I finished already. And second, to answer your first question, He does have a cite I believe.
- I have a question myself. Why isn't Apple and Reed's kits informed as females on the family tree? We know for sure that they are all females. right? ∆ bramble//may –––love paint every afternoon 02:17, April 11, 2015 (UTC)
Cite for Starclan.Edit
Just a few months ago, it was confirmed that Appledusk and the rest of Mapleshade's victims went to Starclan. But that's been taken down now. So why is it invalid? Also could I have a link to see it to see for myself? Mellowix (talk) 15:33, April 24, 2018 (UTC)