Let’s have a look at the facts:

· He disobeyed Bluestar countless times

· He always tried to unite the clans(when there was supposed to be 4 clans).

· He wouldn’t let WindClan solve their problems, by themselves.

· He didn’t punish Brambleclaw when he found out he and Hawkfrost had been plotting.

· He accepted loners, kittypets, and cats from other clans into ThunderClan.

Was Firestar a good leader or was he too soft, post your opinions in the comments.