Am I the only one who has noticed an age issue with Spottedleaf and Brokenstar? Think about it, Spottedleaf (according the the wiki) dies at 4.09 years old, but Brokentail dies at 3.9 years old. That would mean that Spottedleaf was older than Brokentail, but this makes no sense because in the book “Yellowfang’s Secret” Featherwhisker, the medicine cat of ThunderClan says that Spottedkit will be his apprentice next time the medicine cats meet, which would be one moon. This would mean that Spottedkit was 5-6 moons old, but this doesn’t make since because Brokentail is already a full grown warrior, plus deputy of his clan, and leader a few days after Featherwhisker mentions Spottedkit.
Another issue is their death dates, Spottedleaf dies in th…Read more >