Sorry if you think I'm copying you, Hollytail :), but here's the catch - Willowpelt can't be Graystripe's mother. For one thing, it said in Rising Storm that Rainkit, Sootkit, and Sorrelkit were her first litter. Also, Patchpelt and Willowpelt are BROTHER AND SISTER. I honestly wonder what the Erins were thinking when they told us who Graystripe's parents were. Honestly, I'd sooner believe Sandstorm's parents were Redtail and Brindleface. And I'm ready to believe Patchpelt is Graystripe's father, but his mother -
- Dappletail. The Erins revealed that she had a mate and kits. Couldn't Patchpelt have been her mate, and Graystripe her kit?
- Graypool. Yes, Graystripe might not even be fully ThunderClan. I know this sounds ridiculous, but there is a resemblance between the two - they're both long-haired grays. Also, when they recall Oakheart giving Mistykit and Stonekit to Graypool in Forest of Secrets, she had one remaining kit left. Couldn't it have been Graystripe?
- Frostfur, Speckletail, or Goldenflower - don't ask me exactly why, but they were nursery queens for quite a while. They could have had a litter before Into the Wild.
- One-eye. There is a slight resemblance. Just what I'm saying.