After reading the recent list of cats who went to the Place of No Stars, I wondered what exactly makes a cat "evil" enough to be rejected by StarClan- specifically, I'm curious about two cases. My personal opinion is written below, I'd appreciate it if you could tell me yours!
The cat that confused me the most was Lilywhisker. It's been a while since I've read Tallstar's Revenge, so correct me if I'm wrong, please, but I thought she was a sweet, teasing, friendly elder who passed on wisdom about StarClan to her Clanmates and was always kind to Tallstar. Now, according to Su, she was furious about her accident and couldn't "settle her mind" about her fate, which made StarClan reject her and force her to take up residence in the Dark Forest.
I …Read more >