After looking at timelines and average ages of Clan cats, Pinestar could have been the cat to suceed Oakstar. The average age for a Clan cat, even a leader is usually 8 human years of age. It is stated on the wiki that the supposed time between SkyClan's exile and Bluestar is 20 human years. So the dates add up. This would explain the same cats in Cloudstar's Journey, Mapleshade's Vengance, and Code of the Clans, just as Vicky stated on Facebook. Please comment.