Talk: Charart/Tweak Nominations

This is the Project Character Art Tweak Nominations PageDiscussions should be routed to the discussion page, New Art should be routed to the approval page, and all Art Tweaks should be routed to the tweak page.
Template:Project talk
	Archives Approved Archives 1-38 [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] Declined Archives 1-10 [11] [12] [13] [14]

Before editing this page, make sure you are clear on the guidelines for editing it.

TWEAK/REDO NOMINATIONS ARE CURRENTLY: OPEN/CLOSED, BARRING THE NOMINATIONS ALREADY POSTED (see the list below for images to tweak or redo)

Nominations

If you wish to nominate an image, you link the image (like so - [[:File:image.png]]) underneath the appropriate subheading, and list the reason(s) you wish it to be redone/tweaked. Project members with the ranking of warrior or above can vote, and only five votes are necessary for the vote to pass or fail.

Tweaks

Dark Shadow on Water (TB) - Tweak Nomination

File:Dark.tb.png The to-be image has flat shading, and the mud patches look a bit off. If the OA doesn't mind, I'd like this one. Jayie ^{Unwritten words~} 01:20, October 23, 2014 (UTC)

☽➸ Hawky ^{Void Shadowshot}1:48 Thu Oct 23

User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 11:54 AM, Thu Oct 23, 2014

--~☯ Breeze ^{Five Nights at Freddys} 18:02, October 26, 2014 (UTC)

damn that's flat — ferk ^{my name is BLURRYFΛCE} 00:33, 10/28/2014

david ^🌈 01:05, October 28, 2014 (UTC)

Briarlight ~ Tweak Nomination

W, A, Alt A, Ki She has a cite for having dark paws. If the OA's don't want them and if it passes, I'd like this whole set, please. ☽➸ Hawky ^{Void Shadowshot}15:13 Sun Oct 26

You wouldn't mind sharing the alt apprentice would you? User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 3:19 PM, Sun Oct 26, 2014

That's a partial description, Hawky. She's already dark brown =P Queen Beebs 15:27, October 26, 2014 (UTC)

Partial description; but even so, I'd like the warrior and normal apprentice since I still have the files for them. —Jayce(16:03, 10/26/2014)

Partial descriptiooons~! Shinxy used Thunderbolt! 16:34, October 26, 2014 (UTC)

--~☯ Breeze ^{Five Nights at Freddys} 18:01, October 26, 2014 (UTC)

— ferk ^{my name is BLURRYFΛCE} 00:32, 10/28/2014

Swiftstar (WC) - Tweak Nomination

star and leader they don't seem to be the same in terms of coloring, and I think both of them could be darkened just a bit (he's supposed to be dark gray-black and these seem a bit lighter than that) and perhaps the shading could be tweaked to be a bit darker?? Idk, I was browsing the BS characters and he was mentioned and I noticed the images so yeah. If this passes, I'd like both of them. —Jayce(06:59, 10/27/2014) They look the same to me. And they also look dark grey - black to me. Shinxy used Thunderbolt! 11:18, October 27, 2014 (UTC) User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 7:56 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014 They're fine, imo. ☽➸ Hawky ^{Void Shadowshot}20:35 Mon Oct 27

Same as above.--~☯ Breeze ^{Five Nights at Freddys} 00:00, October 28, 2014 (UTC)

They need to be the same. Queen Beebs 00:14, October 28, 2014 (UTC)

they look the same to me tbh — ferk ^{my name is BLURRYFΛCE} 00:34, 10/28/2014

Milkfur (WC) ~ Tweak Nomination

D Flat shading, if this passes and the OA doesn't mind, I'll take it. Shinxy used Thunderbolt! 11:22, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

Jayie ^{Unwritten words~} 13:34, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 7:58 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014

☽➸ Hawky ^{Void Shadowshot}20:35 Mon Oct 27

--~☯ Breeze ^{Five Nights at Freddys} 00:00, October 28, 2014 (UTC)

} doesn't look flat to me — ferk ^{my name is BLURRYFΛCE} 00:36, 10/28/2014

Fernpelt ~ Tweak Nomitation

File:Fernpelt.star.png and File:Fernpelt.apprentice.png Flat Shading. If the OA doesn't want either of these, I'll take the set. User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 8:08 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014

No. But I'm pretty sure Scarlet wants these if they pass since she adores Fernpelt's images. —Jayce(20:13, 10/27/2014)

—.neha ^{it's that gloom boy season.} 20:19, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

I think we're getting too overboard in terms of what looks flat and what's not. Honestly, I think these are fine. ☽➸ Hawky ^{Void Shadowshot}20:36 Mon Oct 27

Hawk, I nominate images because I have a hard time seeing things like shading. Everyone's eyes are different, and mine have sucked as of late. I don't see how we're going overboard with these things, but if you guys just want to vote no, go ahead. (And I'm not saying that in a pissy way, people will vote how they want to vote and if no one else sees a problem with this then that's fine with me.) User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 8:41 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014

mine ~Scarletwind^{"Time to go home Flap."} 21:04, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

--~☯ Breeze ^{Five Nights at Freddys} 23:59, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

— ferk ^{my name is BLURRYFΛCE} 00:38, 10/28/2014

Rain That Rattles on Stones ~ Tweak Nomination

File:Rain.elder.png Flat shading. I'll take it if the OA doesn't want it. User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 8:08 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014

This is so neat how it is please do not touch it. —Jayce(20:15, 10/27/2014)

—.neha ^{it's that gloom boy season.} 20:18, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

It's fine. ☽➸ Hawky ^{Void Shadowshot}20:37 Mon Oct 27

--~☯ Breeze ^{Five Nights at Freddys} 23:59, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

— ferk ^{my name is BLURRYFΛCE} 00:39, 10/28/2014

Bramblestar ~ Tweak Nomination

File:Bramblestar.leader.png Flat shading. I'll take this if the OA doesn't want it Okay that's enough for todayUser:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 8:08 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014

This is not flat. This is more defined than Swiftstar and you voted no. I literally only tweaked this a couple months ago and it's fine. Regardless, it's my image so I will be taking it. —Jayce(20:12, 10/27/2014)

It's fine. —.neha ^{it's that gloom boy season.} 20:18, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

I like this shading. ☽➸ Hawky ^{Void Shadowshot}20:37 Mon Oct 27

Okay then, Cloudy, you don't need to get so upset at me for nominating this, I was having a hard time seeing the shading and I acted accordingly. As for Swiftstar, I was voting no for the color not the shading (tbh I didn't even see the shading). User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 8:41 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014

As I said, it is not flat (to me and obviously a few others), and overly defined shading on this can and does throw the colors off quite badly. We had this issue with the kit too because the shading threw off the colors. —Jayce(20:48, 10/27/2014)

I know you said it was not flat. I understand that others do not find it flat. I found it flat, and I nominated it. I wasn't going to freaky over define it (or ask anyone else to), because I am //legitimately// having a near impossible time seeing it. User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 9:02 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014

It looks fine as it is.--~☯ Breeze ^{Five Nights at Freddys} 23:59, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

how is this even seen as flat. — ferk ^{my name is BLURRYFΛCE} 00:41, 10/28/2014

Redos

Lilyheart (Alt A) - Redo Nomination

File:Lilyheart.apprentice.alt.png Needs to match the alt warrior and alt kit. Unless Hawky wants this, I'd like it. Shinxy used Thunderbolt! 19:58, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

Sorry, but since the alt is part of a set, it needs to match. Should have matched in the first place, but I didn't catch it since I thought it was a different alt. —Jayce(20:02, 10/27/2014)

User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 8:09 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014

Bluestar ^{Leaf flying in the wind} 20:11, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

I'm sorry, but I'll be taking this since its mine. I really hate to get immature about it, but does it really matter if they match or not? Why is it insulting to the artist if I wanted to create something different? I mean, just because its part of a set does /not/ mean they have to match. I decided purposely not to match, otherwise I would have. I'm proud of this and I want it to stay that way. ☽➸ Hawky ^{Void Shadowshot}20:41 Mon Oct 27

Being part of a set is every reason for it to match. Otherwise, none of the images we have would be required to match. Being under the label of "alt" does not mean "is not required to match". It is offensive because the kit got nominated to be redone to match this one when the apprentice should have been the one to match the kit. It does matter, because if we don't match some images, why should we match them at all? —Jayce(20:46, 10/27/2014)

Alright then, you do have a point. However, I still maintain my vote as "nay". ☽➸ Hawky ^{Void Shadowshot}22:32 Mon Oct 27

Where is the whole 'alts have to match' rule anyways? User:Notquiterocketwildbokan/Sig 10:39 PM, Mon Oct 27, 2014

It should not have to be a written rule. If they're part of a set, it should match. All Lilyheart did was go from kit to apprentice, and then warrior, nothing more, nothing less. It's common sense. If you want to add it to the guidelines (which are just that, guidelines), then I'll go and add it myself lmao. —Jayce(22:42, 10/27/2014)

all a different pattern does is make it harder to tell what mistake it's referring to. if it's a standalone alt sure, but this isn't and just makes it harder to tell. david ^🌈 23:20, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

Sorry Hawky; that pattern is amazing, but they do have to match.--~☯ Breeze ^{Five Nights at Freddys} 23:59, October 27, 2014 (UTC)

i hate doing this but if its a set... ;-; — ferk ^{my name is BLURRYFΛCE} 00:42, 10/28/2014

Approved Tweaks

Once an image is under this heading, it may be reserved on the project main page and crossed out with a <s> and a </s>. The image may only be removed from this list when it is approved and archived.

All project leaders are to keep track of the number of images on this list, including those that are crossed out. Should the number rise above 50, nominations will close and remain closed until the number of images on the list is down to 40.

Tweaks

1. File:Beechfur (RC).warrior.png - Flat shading
2. File:Cloudstar.apprentice.png - Flat shading (Reserved to Hawky until November 2)
3. File:Cloudstar.warrior.png - Flat shading (Reserved to Shinx until November 2)
4. File:Cloudstar.deputy.png - Flat shading
5. File:Cloudstar.leader.png - Flat shading (Reserved to Jayce until November 2)
6. File:Cloudstar.star.png - Flat shading (Reserved to Sorrel until November 2)
7. File:Deerleap.star.png - lighten up entire image (Resevred to Trunktail until November 1)
8. File:Ivypool.kit.png -Shading could use defining (Reserved to Sorrel until November 2)

Redos

1. File:Fallowkit.kit.png - Flat shading (Reserved to Jayie until November 2)